Home

iWatch News by The Center for Public Integrity

Follow @iWatch.

Home

About the Center

ICIJ: Global investigations

Donate

Politics

Health

Environment

Accountability

National Security

Juvenile Justice

Environment

Senate bill aims to tighten regulation of oil spill dispersants

By Chris Hamby and Jim Morris

9:57 pm, July 28, 2010 Updated: 3:27 pm, April 19, 2011

Print
E-mail
Tweet

Reacting to health worries about chemical dispersants used in the BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, Democratic Sen. Frank Lautenberg introduced legislation on Wednesday that would require the Environmental Protection Agency to test such compounds and disclose their ingredients.

“In the past three months, BP has dumped more than 1 million gallons of chemical dispersants into the Gulf,” the New Jersey lawmaker said in a statement. “Because these chemicals have not been fully tested, relief workers, families and wildlife up and down the coastline have been put in the middle of a dangerous science experiment.”

A similar measure is part of a broad energy bill in the House.

Lautenberg’s bill comes as some experts voice increasing concern about the long-term health effects of dispersants — and the spilled crude oil itself — on 46,000 Gulf cleanup workers. Eileen Senn, a former compliance officer with the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration and now an industrial hygiene consultant in Ewing, N.J., told the Center for Public Integrity that BP has exposed the workers to airborne chemicals linked to cancer, birth defects, permanent nerve damage and other serious conditions.

Many cleanup workers with the highest exposures over the past 100 days have not worn respirators because of false assurances by BP, said Senn, who is included in regular OSHA conference calls on the situation in the Gulf. “The workers were provided with respirators but they don’t wear them unless alarms go off,” she said. “Those alarms are set at very high levels [by BP].”

A BP spokesman declined to comment on Lautenberg’s bill, but defended the company’s efforts to protect cleanup workers. About 100 experts are monitoring air quality, which shows that workers on the beach don’t need respirators, the company said in a statement. If the need arises offshore, there are enough respirators for all workers on boats near the well. “Workers with health issues are encouraged to report their conditions without fear of reprisal,” the statement said.

An OSHA spokesman also declined to comment on the proposed legislation, saying that the agency had not yet reviewed the bill. “In general, OSHA is in favor of manufacturer transparency when it comes to any chemical ingredient that could pose harm to a worker,” the agency said in a statement. OSHA has conducted its own air monitoring in the Gulf and trained workers there to use respirators, it said. “OSHA has been in the field and on the boats to ensure that BP is doing everything possible to keep workers safe and healthy in the oil spill cleanup,” the statement said.

OSHA said its jurisdiction, however, extends only three nautical miles, with workers farther out being watched by the U.S. Coast Guard or the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement.

Lautenberg’s Senate bill, the Safe Dispersants Act, would mandate EPA testing for acute and chronic effects of dispersants used in oil spill emergencies and require the EPA to study if tougher regulations are needed. It would also ban dispersants “that cannot be proven better for the environment and health than natural or mechanical removal of oil,” and would require makers of dispersants to disclose specific ingredients.

More than 1.8 million gallons of surface and subsurface dispersants have been used in the BP spill. But these chemicals were not required to undergo long-term health or environmental testing and the exact ingredient concentrations of these dispersants have not been made available to the public.

In Senn’s view, the 200 million gallons of crude oil spilled since the April 20 explosion of BP’s Deepwater Horizon pose a far greater risk to workers than the dispersants. The oil, she said, contains solvents such as benzene, a known cause of leukemia, and other toxic substances.

Like our Environment coverage on Facebook and get the latest news instantly.
Advertisement

What we're working on

Projects, series, blogs and other investigations from the Center

Investigation

Consider the Source

Presidential super PACs raise $49 million through December

More stories ...

Investigation

Looting the Seas

'Free-for-all' decimates fish stocks in the southern Pacific

More stories ...

Investigation

Poisoned Places

Many Americans left behind in the quest for cleaner air

More stories ...

Investigation

The Great Mortgage Cover-Up

Countrywide protected fraudsters by silencing whistleblowers, say former employees

More stories ...

Investigation

Juvenile Justice

An epidemic of expulsions

More stories ...

Investigation

Raw Deal

Raging against the foreclosure machine

More stories ...

Popular on Facebook

You might also be interested in ...

Internal e-mails suggest doctoring of oil spill information by White House

Since 9/11, Koch Industries has fought against tougher government rules on chemical plants

After oil spill cleanup, mystery surrounds oil remaining in Gulf

Powered by Calais
Advertisement

Donate

  • Make a donation online

  • Make a donation by mail

  • Make a contribution by fax or phone

  • Make a gift of stock

  • Rated 4-stars on Charity Navigator

Subscribe to our Weekly Watchdog email newsletter to find about our investigations.

What the Center investigates

About the Center

Center in the News

  • Politics

    • One Nation Under Debt
    • Consider the Source
    • Raw Deal
    • Congress
    • The White House
    • Elections
  • Health

    • Medicare
    • Public Health
    • Wendell Potter
    • Island of the Widows
    • Pushing Prescriptions
    • Genetics
  • Environment

    • Health and Safety
    • Energy
    • Pollution
    • Climate
    • Natural Resources
  • Accountability

    • Finance
    • Harmful Error
    • Morning Tip Sheet
    • Education
    • State Integrity Investigation
    • The Truth Left Behind
    • Global Muckraking
    • ICIJ Member Stories
    • Lobby Watch
    • Campaign Consultants
    • Iraq: The War Card
    • Well Connected
    • Waste, Fraud and Abuse
  • National Security

    • Homeland Security
    • The Military
    • Intelligence
    • Outsourcing the Pentagon
    • Windfalls of War
  • Juvenile Justice

    • About The Center for Public Integrity

    • Our Organization

    • Our People

    • Our Work

    • About the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists

    • Contact Us

    • Advertise

    • Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

    • John Dunbar talks year-end super PAC disclosure on PBS NewsHour

    • Center, NPR finalist for Goldsmith journalism prize

    • Weekly Watchdog 1/26/12

    • John Dunbar discusses super PACs on PBS NewsHour

    • International Consortium Adds 41 Investigative Journalists

    • The weekly watchdog: Dec. 12 - Dec. 16

    • Center garners top journalism awards

    • The weekly watchdog: Dec. 5 - Dec. 9

    Copyright 2012 The Center for Public Integrity

    Supported by: