Home

iWatch News by The Center for Public Integrity

Follow @iWatch.

Home

About the Center

ICIJ: Global investigations

Donate

Politics

Health

Environment

Accountability

National Security

Juvenile Justice

Environment : Energy : Coal Ash

Coal ash debate now moves to minefilling

By Kristen Lombardi

7:34 pm, February 19, 2009 Updated: 12:26 pm, June 10, 2011

Print
E-mail
Tweet

Ever since that disastrous late December coal-ash spill in Eastern Tennessee, Congressional attention has focused on one federal agency — the Environmental Protection Agency. But as lawmakers pressure the EPA to regulate coal ash — the often toxic solid waste generated by burning coal for electricity, and the focus of a new Center investigation — environmentalists are also nervously eyeing the draft of a proposed rule floated by the Interior Department — and praying it’ll forever fade.

The proposed rule, drawn up by the Interior Department’s Office of Surface Mining, Reclamation and Enforcement, and circulated to interest groups by the office itself, would establish national standards for the controversial practice of “minefilling,” or placing coal ash in active and abandoned mines. In the 92-page document, a copy of which was obtained by PaperTrail, the office lays out provisions under the federal surface-mining law that would govern minefill sites, as well as new requirements for their permitting. The office writes, “We intend for these regulations to minimize the possibility that placement of [coal ash] could cause adverse impacts on public health and the environment.”

But that’s not how environmentalists see it. When word of the draft proposed rule first surfaced in late December, 40 groups signed onto a 10-page letter addressed to then-President-Elect Obama that called the draft “egregiously irresponsible” and urged the incoming administration to “send the rule back to OSM.” As it stands, they wrote, “The proposed Office of Surface Mining rule would turn the nation’s coal mines into massive open dumps for non-mine generated industrial waste.” They are particularly concerned because, in their view, the rule would allow coal ash to seep into groundwater.

John Craynon, the office’s chief of regulatory support (a career position, not a political appointment), disputes the environmental groups’ characterization of the proposed rule. “We feel it addresses the concerns of the National Academy of Sciences,” he told Papertrail, referring to the Academy’s July 2006 report on minefilling. The draft reflects, in his words, “all the recommendations and all the comments on all sides of the issue.”

In recent weeks, after the White House Office of Management and Budget held the proposed rule’s review because of the change in administration, Craynon has circulated copies of it among industry and environmental groups alike. “The previous director of the bureau decided that it was a good thing,” he explains, although he stresses that the draft doesn’t necessarily represent the office’s preference today. “All I can say is that it was where we were headed before the change in administration.”

Whether Obama appointees heed the environmentalists’ desire to scratch the proposed rule altogether is anyone’s guess. Craynon says it can take months to fill his office’s directorship. “We’ll be using this draft as a starting point to discuss the issue with the new folks in charge,” he says.

Follow PaperTrail on Twitter, become our fan on Facebook, and subscribe to the Center’s YouTube account to keep up to date with our latest investigations and blog posts.

Like our Environment coverage on Facebook and get the latest news instantly.
Advertisement

What we're working on

Projects, series, blogs and other investigations from the Center

Investigation

Consider the Source

Democratic operatives seeking million-dollar checks for super PACs

More stories ...

Investigation

Looting the Seas

'Free-for-all' decimates fish stocks in the southern Pacific

More stories ...

Investigation

Poisoned Places

Many Americans left behind in the quest for cleaner air

More stories ...

Investigation

The Great Mortgage Cover-Up

Countrywide protected fraudsters by silencing whistleblowers, say former employees

More stories ...

Investigation

Juvenile Justice

An epidemic of expulsions

More stories ...

Investigation

Raw Deal

Raging against the foreclosure machine

More stories ...

Popular on Facebook

You might also be interested in ...

EPA scolded for website that appeared to endorse coal ash products

Democrats join fight against coal ash regulation

EPA not ready to name coal ash locations

Powered by Calais
Advertisement

Donate

  • Make a donation online

  • Make a donation by mail

  • Make a contribution by fax or phone

  • Make a gift of stock

  • Rated 4-stars on Charity Navigator

Subscribe to our Weekly Watchdog email newsletter to find about our investigations.

What the Center investigates

About the Center

Center in the News

  • Politics

    • One Nation Under Debt
    • Consider the Source
    • Raw Deal
    • Congress
    • The White House
    • Elections
  • Health

    • Medicare
    • Public Health
    • Wendell Potter
    • Island of the Widows
    • Pushing Prescriptions
    • Genetics
  • Environment

    • Health and Safety
    • Energy
    • Pollution
    • Climate
    • Natural Resources
  • Accountability

    • Finance
    • Harmful Error
    • Morning Tip Sheet
    • Education
    • State Integrity Investigation
    • The Truth Left Behind
    • Global Muckraking
    • ICIJ Member Stories
    • Lobby Watch
    • Campaign Consultants
    • Iraq: The War Card
    • Well Connected
    • Waste, Fraud and Abuse
  • National Security

    • Homeland Security
    • The Military
    • Intelligence
    • Outsourcing the Pentagon
    • Windfalls of War
  • Juvenile Justice

    • About The Center for Public Integrity

    • Our Organization

    • Our People

    • Our Work

    • About the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists

    • Contact Us

    • Advertise

    • Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

    • Susan Ferriss discusses youth in prison with KQED

    • Weekly Watchdog 2/2/12

    • John Dunbar talks year-end super PAC disclosure on PBS NewsHour

    • Center, NPR finalist for Goldsmith journalism prize

    • Weekly Watchdog 1/26/12

    • John Dunbar discusses super PACs on PBS NewsHour

    • International Consortium Adds 41 Investigative Journalists

    • The weekly watchdog: Dec. 12 - Dec. 16

    Copyright 2012 The Center for Public Integrity

    Supported by: