Home

iWatch News by The Center for Public Integrity

Follow @iWatch.

Home

About the Center

ICIJ: Global investigations

Donate

Politics

Health

Environment

Accountability

National Security

Juvenile Justice

Politics : Congress : The Transportation Lobby

Stimulus for planes, trains, but mostly automobiles.

By Joe Eaton

11:59 pm, January 15, 2009 Updated: 3:33 pm, April 19, 2011

Print
E-mail
Tweet

The big winner in the $825 billion stimulus proposal revealed Thursday by House Democrats is roads. State road projects get a proposed at $30 billion, while mass-transit projects got only $10 billion.

“It’s more of the same,” said David Goldberg, communications director for Transportation for America, a coalition of reform-minded housing, environmental, public health, urban planning, and transportation groups. “If we have a dollar left over after we build the last highway, we will build the stuff that allows people to get to work when traffic is too nightmarish and gas prices are too high.”

The legislation comes after months of lobbying by opposing forces. Mass transit advocates wanted to require states to repair older roads rather than building new ones, which they believe could encourage sprawl. Meanwhile, roads groups like the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials argued that the feds should pass transportation money along to the state DOTs and let them decide how to spend.

“[States and local governments] don’t need help from inside-the-beltway advocacy groups to make those decisions for them,” said John Horsley, the association’s executive director.

The states had sent their wish lists of “shovel ready” projects to Washington in anticipation of the stimulus proposal. The lists are heavy on road building (often in rural areas) and short on public transpiration and bicycle and pedestrian projects. Several states included no proposals for mass transit or rail. Some have suggested that is because they did not have plans ready to submit.

Mass transit proponents say the legislation is sure to put people to work, but will do little to improve transportation. “It is the worst way to spend economic stimulus money,” Christopher Leinberger, a real estate developer and Brookings fellow, said of the legislation. “This is a very bad move if we want to achieve energy independence and if we want to achieve a green economy.”

Like our Politics coverage on Facebook and get the latest news instantly.
Advertisement

What we're working on

Projects, series, blogs and other investigations from the Center

Investigation

Consider the Source

Another Bain exec revealed as man behind corporate donor to pro-Romney super PAC

More stories ...

Investigation

Looting the Seas

'Free-for-all' decimates fish stocks in the southern Pacific

More stories ...

Investigation

Poisoned Places

Many Americans left behind in the quest for cleaner air

More stories ...

Investigation

The Great Mortgage Cover-Up

Countrywide protected fraudsters by silencing whistleblowers, say former employees

More stories ...

Investigation

Juvenile Justice

An epidemic of expulsions

More stories ...

Investigation

Raw Deal

Raging against the foreclosure machine

More stories ...

Popular on Facebook

Advertisement

Donate

  • Make a donation online

  • Make a donation by mail

  • Make a contribution by fax or phone

  • Make a gift of stock

  • Rated 4-stars on Charity Navigator

Subscribe to our Weekly Watchdog email newsletter to find about our investigations.

What the Center investigates

About the Center

Center in the News

  • Politics

    • One Nation Under Debt
    • Consider the Source
    • Raw Deal
    • Congress
    • The White House
    • Elections
  • Health

    • Medicare
    • Public Health
    • Wendell Potter
    • Island of the Widows
    • Pushing Prescriptions
    • Genetics
  • Environment

    • Health and Safety
    • Energy
    • Pollution
    • Climate
    • Natural Resources
  • Accountability

    • Finance
    • Harmful Error
    • Morning Tip Sheet
    • Education
    • State Integrity Investigation
    • The Truth Left Behind
    • Global Muckraking
    • ICIJ Member Stories
    • Lobby Watch
    • Campaign Consultants
    • Iraq: The War Card
    • Well Connected
    • Waste, Fraud and Abuse
  • National Security

    • Homeland Security
    • The Military
    • Intelligence
    • Outsourcing the Pentagon
    • Windfalls of War
  • Juvenile Justice

    • About The Center for Public Integrity

    • Our Organization

    • Our People

    • Our Work

    • About the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists

    • Contact Us

    • Advertise

    • Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

    • Susan Ferriss discusses youth in prison with KQED

    • Weekly Watchdog 2/2/12

    • John Dunbar talks year-end super PAC disclosure on PBS NewsHour

    • Center, NPR finalist for Goldsmith journalism prize

    • Weekly Watchdog 1/26/12

    • John Dunbar discusses super PACs on PBS NewsHour

    • International Consortium Adds 41 Investigative Journalists

    • The weekly watchdog: Dec. 12 - Dec. 16

    Copyright 2012 The Center for Public Integrity

    Supported by: