Home

iWatch News by The Center for Public Integrity

Follow @iWatch.

Home

About the Center

ICIJ: Global investigations

Donate

Politics

Health

Environment

Accountability

National Security

Juvenile Justice

Accountability

A good time to be a white-collar criminal?

Possible mortgage loan fraud spikes, but pursuit of white-collar crime slows

By Nick Schwellenbach

10:43 pm, December 18, 2008 Updated: 11:21 am, March 20, 2011

Print
E-mail
Tweet

The Securities and Exchange Commission has said that it failed to pursue a variety of allegations about Bernard Madoff’s alleged Ponzi scheme, which may have cost investors as much as $50 billion. But that admission may be part of a larger problem, according to recent statistics: the government’s apparent laxity in investigating various white-collar crimes. Case in point: mortgage fraud.

A division of the Treasury Department known as the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, or FinCEN, by law gets reports from banks about possible mortgage loan fraud incidents they have spotted. Banks reported 4,696 suspected mortgage fraud incidents in 2001, but that ballooned over 10 times to 52,868 in 2007, according to an April 2008 FinCEN report.

These reports do not mean a crime has been committed, but they can lead to criminal investigations.

However, the FBI’s work in pursuing white-collar cases, which include mortgage fraud and various other crimes, has dropped dramatically since 2001. There has been a nearly 82 percent drop in white-collar criminal prosecutions between 2001 and 2007, the Syracuse University-based Transactional Records and Access Clearinghouse found, using Justice Department data. (Justice only recently started breaking out mortgage fraud cases.)

Part of that drop can be explained by the post-9/11 diversion of the FBI resources to national security. Since 2001, there has been a 36 percent drop in the number of agents assigned to white-collar crime, causing the FBI to struggle in investigating mortgage fraud and other white-collar crimes, according to The New York Times. Over approximately the same time period, the issuance of subprime loans grew dramatically.

Though few of the reports to FinCEN mention what kind of loans were in question, “subprime mortgage issues remain a key factor in influencing mortgage fraud directly and indirectly,” the FBI stated in a 2007 report. And as early as 2004, the FBI took note of the consequences that questionable mortgage lending could have on the economy.

“The potential impact of mortgage fraud on financial institutions and the stock market is clear,” Chris Swecker, former FBI assistant director, testified before Congress in 2004. “If fraudulent practices become systemic within the mortgage industry and mortgage fraud is allowed to become unrestrained, it will ultimately place financial institutions at risk and have adverse effects on the stock market.”

But some question whether the government did enough, despite the FBI’s acknowledgement of the problem.

Incoming Florida Representative Alan Grayson, a Democrat, whose state has been particularly impacted by the housing crisis, said, “I can’t recall a single case they prosecuted regarding these [subprime] loans.”

“It’s as if a building was burning down right next to the fire station,” he said, “and the fire department claimed it didn’t notice.”

Like our Accountability coverage on Facebook and get the latest news instantly.
Advertisement

What we're working on

Projects, series, blogs and other investigations from the Center

Investigation

Consider the Source

Democratic operatives seeking million-dollar checks for super PACs

More stories ...

Investigation

Looting the Seas

'Free-for-all' decimates fish stocks in the southern Pacific

More stories ...

Investigation

Poisoned Places

Many Americans left behind in the quest for cleaner air

More stories ...

Investigation

The Great Mortgage Cover-Up

Countrywide protected fraudsters by silencing whistleblowers, say former employees

More stories ...

Investigation

Juvenile Justice

An epidemic of expulsions

More stories ...

Investigation

Raw Deal

Raging against the foreclosure machine

More stories ...

Popular on Facebook

You might also be interested in ...

Feds investigating possible fraud at GE’s former subprime unit

GOP candidates in foreclosure capital say government not the solution to crisis

Methodology

Powered by Calais
Advertisement

Donate

  • Make a donation online

  • Make a donation by mail

  • Make a contribution by fax or phone

  • Make a gift of stock

  • Rated 4-stars on Charity Navigator

Subscribe to our Weekly Watchdog email newsletter to find about our investigations.

What the Center investigates

About the Center

Center in the News

  • Politics

    • One Nation Under Debt
    • Consider the Source
    • Raw Deal
    • Congress
    • The White House
    • Elections
  • Health

    • Medicare
    • Public Health
    • Wendell Potter
    • Island of the Widows
    • Pushing Prescriptions
    • Genetics
  • Environment

    • Health and Safety
    • Energy
    • Pollution
    • Climate
    • Natural Resources
  • Accountability

    • Finance
    • Harmful Error
    • Morning Tip Sheet
    • Education
    • State Integrity Investigation
    • The Truth Left Behind
    • Global Muckraking
    • ICIJ Member Stories
    • Lobby Watch
    • Campaign Consultants
    • Iraq: The War Card
    • Well Connected
    • Waste, Fraud and Abuse
  • National Security

    • Homeland Security
    • The Military
    • Intelligence
    • Outsourcing the Pentagon
    • Windfalls of War
  • Juvenile Justice

    • About The Center for Public Integrity

    • Our Organization

    • Our People

    • Our Work

    • About the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists

    • Contact Us

    • Advertise

    • Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

    • Susan Ferriss discusses youth in prison with KQED

    • Weekly Watchdog 2/2/12

    • John Dunbar talks year-end super PAC disclosure on PBS NewsHour

    • Center, NPR finalist for Goldsmith journalism prize

    • Weekly Watchdog 1/26/12

    • John Dunbar discusses super PACs on PBS NewsHour

    • International Consortium Adds 41 Investigative Journalists

    • The weekly watchdog: Dec. 12 - Dec. 16

    Copyright 2012 The Center for Public Integrity

    Supported by: